Member #61,905 signed up 10/9/2008
1 to 3 of 23
6,790 Tasting Notes
8,992 Tasting Notes
52 Tasting Notes
1 to 3 of 10
52 Tasting Notes
318 Tasting Notes
87 Tasting Notes
1 to 3 of 5
318 Tasting Notes
5,958 Tasting Notes
1,325 Tasting Notes
This member's profile is not public.
2000 Château Pontet-Canet
5/10/2024 - Brad T Likes this wine: 97 Points
On P&P, I was immediately accosted by that heady "old wine barrel in a cave" scent that to me is what secondary flavors and scents are all about in the best Cabernet based wines, with serious but lovely cow sh*t perfume. I view cow shi*t as the midpoint between the acridity of pig sh*t and the weedy scent of horse shi*t. [As an aside, I like the horse sh*t end of the shit spectrum, but still prefer the middle point of cow sh*t. I don't dig the pig sh*t stank, personally, but I don't view myself as an expert sh*t-sniffer, so my opinions may be sh*t.] So the nose was just effusive, yet there was nothing suggesting the wine was too ripe/overly extracted/too alcoholic/oxidized. The first sip was magical, and it rapidly got better over the hour it lasted. The palate was akin to the brambly St. Juliens I've loved most, crossed with the big boy Pauillacs that get the big scores. On the top, I got beautiful medium cigar box and light cedar, and with time, the copious cassis notes were stunning. Lots of dark, damp earth and surprisingly fresh, deep dark fruit, with minimal residual sweetness. This to me is an outstanding Bordeaux that’s in the middle of its prime drinking window. It speaks to what makes Bordeaux the king of French wines and one of the greatest wine regions in the world.
2 people found this helpful, do you? Yes - No / Comment
2013 Jean Edwards Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Seventy Four - Forty One Napa Valley
4/21/2024 - Brad T Likes this wine: 93 Points
The two preceding notes are quite accurate. The chocolate and cherry or raspberry notes are propulsive, yet this wine has been softening and is in a beautiful place now. This wine has been steadily growing more complex with each bottle I’ve opened, and its future remains equally open. This is an unusually well made Napa Cab. Wish they were all made with such a judicious touch.
Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment
2014 Turley Zinfandel Dragon Vineyard
3/11/2024 - Brad T wrote: flawed
Hoping this is just a bad bottle as I’m a Dragon lover and this one had a bitter and awkward finish.
Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment