Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(1,099 comments on 884 notes)

1 - 50 of 884 Sort order
Red
2016 Château d'Aiguilhe Castillon Côtes de Bordeaux Red Bordeaux Blend
2/26/2024 - belfast taxman wrote:
91 points
Dark full-bodied with a lush texture and nicely balanced tannins. There is fruit cake and an element of blueberry that I often find in Merlot dominated wines. The equal of many a St Emilion grand cru (though not quite Classe) and an added mark for vfm in the context of Bordeaux.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    5/6/24, 4:47 AM - Thank you for your note. I used to like the 2009 quite a bit when it was young, and the 2010 at six, seven years of age, and agree that this Château typically offers excellent value for money (in Bordeaux terms). That said, I have lost track of the bottling after the disappointing 2011, and should probably try a few younger vintages like this 2016.

Red
2008 Hartenberg Cabernet Sauvignon Stellenbosch
4/30/2024 - PSPatrick wrote:
91 points
Good dark and red fruit, dark cherry, leafy black currant, some bell pepper, vegetal notes, chocolate, espresso, tobacco, intense spice notes, smoke, and mint, with medium-level acidity, mostly resolved and well-integrated tannin, and good length. Medium-bodied, with a lightly creamy texture, average concentration, and good balance. A little rustic on the finish, but somewhat intriguing overall. Very South African! And full of character. In a good place. I suggest drinking now and over the next four or five years.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    5/6/24, 4:40 AM - I toured wineries in the Cape region in 2019, but did not make it to Hartenberg, unfortunately. I have heard good things about the Paul Sauer and realize that I have a few bottles of 2011 and 2012 in the cellar but have never tried one yet. Need to find those bottles. Thank you for the recommendation!

White
2014 Hartenberg Chardonnay Stellenbosch
4/30/2024 - PSPatrick wrote:
90 points
The back label of this wine says "Drink now or keep for up to three years from vintage". Hartenberg should have more faith in the quality of their wines! Youthful-looking bright medium yellow. Lemon, ripe grapefruit, apple, quince, tropical notes, toast, oak spice, and light smoke, with good acidity, and very good length. Medium- to full-bodied, with good concentration and complexity, a lightly creamy texture, and very good persistence. Equally good on day two. Very youthful. Drink now, and for at least another five years.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    5/6/24, 4:33 AM - Thank you for your feedback and comment! I have had a few different vintages of the Harten-berg Chardonnay and liked all of them quite a bit at about age 7 to 11 years from vintage. The Hartenberg Chardonnay’s indeed age well and offer excellent value for money. But I do not have a good overview of South African Chardonnays in general: I have tried Chardonnay’s from about 15 different producers in South Africa, with some good results (Delaire Graff's Chardonnay Re-serve Banghoek showed particularly well), but I typically opt for Chenin Blanc instead. That said, I had the Hamilton Russel 1997 at age 24 and it was still enjoyable if, admittedly, on the down-ward sloop. I never got a chance to try the Five Soldiers or the Eleanor though and am thankful for your feedback on the two.

Red
2000 Château Lynch-Bages Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
4/10/2024 - PSPatrick wrote:
92 points
Bottle in perfect condition, cork pristine. Decanted for three hours. Medium garnet colour, very little sediment. Cherry, black currant, plum, cedar, tobacco, light coffee, light chocolate, spices, graphite, gravelly minerality, and a high-end balsamic vinegar note after further breathing, with fresh acidity, well-integrated tannin, and great persistence. Medium-bodied, balanced, and fresh, with impressive structure. Still firm and restrained, reminding me of many Bordeaux of the 1995 vintage. Holds a lot of promise, but for now the value for money is off. I would love to try this again in ten years! 92(++)
  • PSPatrick commented:

    4/22/24, 6:32 AM - Yes, at €25-30 a bottle we would probably be drinking Lynch-Bages all the time! And your 1996 should drink well now, I presume. The 2000 was still firm and restrained, which is consistent with a few other top 2000s I tried recently. For that reason, at the moment I would rather drink 2003s and 2004s, and hold the 2000s for a few years, at least at the top levels. I have not had any 2005s lately and will need to try a few to find out where they are in terms of evolution. Have you? Any thoughts?

Red
2001 Château La Gomerie St. Émilion Red Bordeaux Blend
4/18/2024 - PSPatrick wrote:
90 points
Poured at our office opening in Singapore. No formal notes. Medium garnet colour. Red and black fruit, leather, tobacco, espresso, some chocolate, autumn leaves, vegetal and herbaceous notes, and spices, with medium-plus acidity and very good length. The tannin is round and fine if dry and lightly chewy, and the acidity is slightly pronounced, making the wine feel just a little angular. But it drinks quite well overall. Drink now.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    4/21/24, 7:22 AM - Sure, will do!

Red
2015 Château d'Issan Margaux Red Bordeaux Blend
3/12/2024 - PSPatrick wrote:
92 points
Bought today, at Central Perk Wine & Spirits, 1420 6th Avenue, New York. A blend of 65% Cabernet Sauvignon and 35% Merlot, aged in oak, 50% new. Popped and poured. A little closed on day one, more open on day two. Medium to dark garnet colour. Black currant, dark cherry, blackberry, plum, a musty/vegetal aspect that adds complexity, pencil shaving, chocolate, cocoa, espresso, tobacco, spices, liquorice, and light vanilla, with good acidity, well-integrated tannin, and very good length. Medium-bodied, with good concentration, and a creamy texture. Quite enjoyable. Ready now.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    3/15/24, 8:51 AM - With no decanter available, popped and poured and straight from bottle, it is surprising that the wine was enjoyable already, and that it was fully open on day two. If you give it just some aeration in a decanter, it is ready to drink now.

  • PSPatrick commented:

    4/11/24, 8:10 AM - @macaujames: That sounds exciting indeed. Looking forward to hearing more! With limited exposure to Château d'Issan in the past due to a few early disappointments, I find the more recent releases much more compelling than pre-2015 vintages I have had.

Red
1986 Château Canon St. Émilion Grand Cru Red Bordeaux Blend
2/25/2024 - pavel_p Likes this wine:
93 points
Revisiting an old friend... Almost 3 years after my last bottle, this was again a super showing and the wine is still in its peak drinking window for my taste. Slow ox'ed for about 2h. This delivers all one hopes for in a mature Bordeaux, beautifully balanced and aromatic with cigar box, leather and still some dark fruit. 80s Canon are great, whether its 85, 86 or 89 (yet to try the 82).
  • PSPatrick commented:

    4/7/24, 1:55 AM - Fully agree on the quality of the Canons from the 80's, and would also throw '83 in the mix of the vintages you mentioned.

Red
2015 Château de Beaucastel Châteauneuf-du-Pape Red Rhone Blend
3/6/2024 - macaujames Likes this wine:
95 points
94/95. 0.375. Has fantastic aromas of blackberries ,black olives, iron, mint, five spice and blueberries! Profound lightly spicy garriguey leathery, lightly earthy, vanilla-ery lacy, satiny ironey blue red and black fruited wine with lovely long refreshing and tapering finish with nice gripping tannin. 14.5%. Drink now with 8-9 hrs aeration or lay down 15-30 yrs no problem.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    3/7/24, 12:51 AM - I can see why you liked the 2015 Beaucastel. I only tried it once, when it was very young, and was impressed. I put a case in storage and will probably leave it there for another five years. The 2007 is amazing now, by the way.

Red
2019 Domaine Chante Cigale Châteauneuf-du-Pape Red Rhone Blend
3/4/2024 - PSPatrick wrote:
92 points
A blend of 65% Grenache, 20% Syrah, 10% Mourvèdre, and 5% Cinsault. 15% ABV. Medium to dark ruby colour. Wild berries on the nose. Sweet berry fruit, chocolate, garrigue, pastille, spices, vanilla, liquorice, black tea, and stony minerality on the palate, with medium-minus acidity, firm tannin that is hidden underneath the generous fruit, and very good length. Medium to full body, with good concentration, and notable sweetness from the ripe fruit and high alcohol. The wine benefited from aeration, and the tannin softened and the wine found balance after about an hour in the decanter, but it remained tight. Consistent on days two and three. Impressive for a standard cuvée! Needs some time to soften the tannin and open up. I would hold, and only drink from 2027.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    3/7/24, 12:49 AM - On sale at Schreiblehner, recently, very good value at €29. The 2000 I had a few years ago also showed well, very ethereal. I bought a bottle of each of the 2019 CdP Vieilles Vignes, 2021 CdP Pi, and 2022 Blanc as well and intend to try them over the next few weeks.

Red
2011 R. López de Heredia Rioja Reserva Viña Tondonia Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
2/26/2024 - PSPatrick wrote:
91 points
Decanted for two hours. Red fruit, cherry, mixed berries, dill, chocolate, espresso, spices, clove, and vanilla, with good, slightly pronounced acidity, ripe, well-integrated tannin, and great persistence. Medium-bodied and well-balanced, with a creamy texture. Classic! But restrained, and not ready yet. Needs time. I suggest holding your bottles for four or five years, and to start drinking from 2029. 91(+)(?)
  • PSPatrick commented:

    2/29/24, 12:56 AM - Can't say, I am sorry. I have not tried the 2010 yet. If I had to guess, I would expect the 2010 to be superior, more structured, firmer, and longer lived based on vintage. I am a little jealous, I missed the opportunity to secure me a case.

Red
2012 Ziereisen Rhini Baden Spätburgunder, Pinot Noir
9/18/2022 - Gerhard3 wrote:
87 points
I had expected the Ziereisen to be better than the Bourgogne from a modest Appelation (René Bouvier Marsannay Le Finage 2017) tasted in parallel, but well, it wasn't, at least not according to my taste. The wood (70% used, 30% new) prevented the fruit from singing, even though the aroma is quite noble (more in the walnut/peanut department than coconut and vanilla). In the mouth, the wood was too powerful as well, even though all the rest was fine (medium volume, good acidity, good tannins).
  • PSPatrick commented:

    2/16/24, 6:27 AM - I agree with your conclusion. Despite of the reputation of the producer and the warm vintage, the wine is pretty harsh on the palate, an rustic overall, and does not provide much pleasure.

Red
2018 Château Pichon-Longueville Baron Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
2/6/2024 - PSPatrick wrote:
95 points
Half-bottle. Very tight upon opening, so I decanted the wine for three hours in a small decanter which did the trick. Dark ruby colour. Ripe dark and red fruit, ripe black currant, dark cherry, ripe blackberry, ripe blueberry, kirsch, dark plum, dark chocolate, cocoa, espresso, graphite, cedar, spices, and vanilla, with medium-level acidity, ripe, round tannin, and very good length. Intriguing sweetness from the fruit and the well-integrated oak. Great structure and impressive, almost oily concentration. Wow! The best young Bordeaux I have had in some time.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    2/12/24, 8:41 AM - I have had a few nice young Bordeaux recently, slowly working through a mixed case of 24 different half bottles of crus classés (mostly from the 2016 to 2020 vintages). 2015 Brane-Cantenac was very accessible and quite beautiful, and 2020 Beausejour Duffau Lagarrosse had impressive structure, concentration and complexity (but needs time). But the 2018 Pichon Baron stood out. It breaks the bank, but I could not help it, I had to get a case and put it into storage.

    I have never had the Thalabert. Thank you for mentioning it. Will keep my eyes open.

Red
1987 La Rioja Alta Rioja Viña Ardanza Reserva Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
1/22/2024 - PSPatrick wrote:
91 points
Bottle in good condition. Ullage of 2.5 cm. Cork completely soaked, but minimal seepage. Medium to light brick-ish colour, some sediment. Red fruit, red cherry, dill, leather, tobacco, earth, coffee, spices, light chocolate, and ethereal notes, with good, slightly pronounced acidity, fully resolved tannin, and very good length. Classic mature Rioja profile, yet not quite as smooth as one would expect from a 30+ year-old Rioja. On day two, the wine is even more mature, the red fruit is more on the dried side, and joined by mushroom and earth, with a smoother texture. Not quite on the same level as the 1985. Still, it would be interesting to try this again in five years from now. Drink up over the next eight to ten years.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    1/30/24, 9:23 AM - @macaujames: Always happy to taste a wine for you ;)
    I bought a few bottles of 85, 87 and 89 Ardanza Reserva from different sources recently. From the bottles I sourced the 85 showed best; a classic, mature, smoothly textured and well-balanced Rioja. The 87 also showed well, even if not as smoothly textured as one would expect from a 30+ year-old wine. The 89 was a little mor difficult, the acidity was pronounced and there was some bitterness on the finish. There will be a lot of bottle variation depending on provenance, but based on the bottle I had it might be worth checking in on your bottles of 89 to see how they are doing.

  • PSPatrick commented:

    1/30/24, 9:37 AM - @belfast taxman: I agree, it really is impressive how well many Riojas age, even at Reserva level. I have had amazing Reservas from the 60s and 70s and love the style. But I admit that I have had mixed experiences with aged Ardanza Reservas recently and will now monitor their development very closely once they are 25+ years old.
    Château Prieuré-Lichine is a different story for me since I used to like the Château a lot, in par-ticular for the value for money, and the 86, 88 and 89 have aged very well and still are beautiful wines. That said, I am disappointed with the vintages of the 90s and early 2000s, and have start-ed to sell my stock in 1999, 2000 and 2001 Château Prieuré-Lichine. I had also bought 2015 and 2019, which I have not tried yet, and hope that they are back to the old standards...

Red
2018 Julia Bertram Spätburgunder Handwerk Ahr
9/26/2022 - macaujames Likes this wine:
90 points
90/91. Has come on! Has aromas of flowers, basalt hints and coffee and cherry hints. Its medium bodied supple blue and red fruits palate has got nice linear depth and finishes medium, fresh and tapering. Lay down 2 years. 12%.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    1/27/24, 3:11 AM - In case you are interested, Wein-Refugium currently runs a sale and some Bertram wines are available at a 30% discount. The Frühburgunder is exceptional. I also recommend Holger Koch’s Pinot Noirs, in particular Holger Koch’s Spätburgunder *** 2016.

Red
2019 Envinate Taganan Parcela Margalagua Canary Islands Red Blend
12/8/2023 - PSPatrick wrote:
90 points
Only 12% ABV. Very funky initially, but the funk mostly subsided with aeration, and gave way to red fruit and some blue and black fruit, pomegranate, and volcanic and saline minerality, with good acidity, well-integrated tannin, and very good length. Smoothly textured and very well balanced. Drinks well on day one. On day two, the wine still shows some funk, and has a more mature profile, with dried red fruit, dried cherry and dried pomegranate, but also with dry, medium grained tannin no longer covered by the fruit. I have no idea how this wine will age. My best educated guess is to drink the wine young (as in by now) or to wait for at least ten years.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    12/26/23, 12:54 AM - Agree. The salty and volcanic character makes these wines quite unique. The Envinate wines are my favourite so far, and for a more oaky style maybe the Suertes del Marqués Vidonia from Tenerife.

Red
2001 Château Prieuré-Lichine Margaux Red Bordeaux Blend
12/18/2023 - PSPatrick wrote:
88 points
Decanted for one hour in the morning, poured over dinner. 13% ABV. Medium to dark garnet colour, some sediment. Complex aromatics. Red and dark fruit, bubble gum, vegetal notes, cedar, tobacco, spices, some chocolate, and light smoke, with good acidity, unresolved and lightly rustic tannin, and good length. Lightly rustic and slightly underripe, and lacking sufficient juice to counter the unresolved tannin at this point. Benefited from further aeration in the evening. Very different from two stunning bottles I shared with family ten years ago. Might be an in-between phase?
  • PSPatrick commented:

    12/23/23, 3:28 AM - Now that is a good question. Funnily, I am not sure. I think it was Filet Mignon (no sauce). It must not have worked well since if it had softened the tannin I would have included it in my note.

Red
2018 Schiavenza Barolo Serralunga d'Alba Nebbiolo
11/16/2023 - rickspicks wrote:
88 points
This tastes like an entr-level Barolo that I found to drink older than its age. The fruits tasted a bit dried-out and lacking vibrancy, freshness and richness. The flavors that are there are appropriate - cherry and spice, but I don't see this as a 92 point wine.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    12/11/23, 12:00 AM - Agree 100%. I was surprised by the lack of freshness and by how developed the wine tasted. I am generally cautious with 2017 and 2018 Barolos but found that some are dinking well early on. This one may never shine...

Red
2015 Château de Haute-Serre Cahors Géron Dadine de Haute-Serre Cuvée Prestige Malbec
11/9/2017 - PSPatrick wrote:
90 points
Retailer tasting. The wine was dark purple in colour and offered floral notes, nice dark fruit aromas, graphite and hints of coffee and chocolate on the nose and palate, with medium-level acidity, fine, medium-plus tannin and superb length. The wine was well structured, balanced and complete. The quality of tannin and the length stood out. A very good wine; I bought a case. Interestingly, I was the only customer tonight that bought a case of this wine, most other customers were leaning towards the riper and broader styles of the Roussillon wines. 90+ for now, with potential to improve.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    1/9/18, 5:36 AM - I haven't had it before, but am very curious how it develops over the next 25 years or so!

  • PSPatrick commented:

    12/8/23, 10:36 PM - Nice! I haven't tried an Haut-Serre in a while. And your comment raises the question where I have buried the case of this Cuvée Prestige which I bought at the time... ?!?

Red
2010 La Rioja Alta Rioja Viña Ardanza Reserva Selección Especial Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
11/27/2023 - macaujames Likes this wine:
94 points
94/95. In 5 years+ this will be a 95. A profound lightly sandstoney, vanillary, minty, leathery blue and black fruits wine with excellent zingy length! My last couple of glasses. 13.5%. Needs 8-9 hrs aeration. Wonderful value at 23 Euros. I wish I had more. Will try the 2016 at Christmas 2024.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    12/4/23, 10:03 PM - The Ardanza seems to be replacing the 904 of the earlier 2000s in terms of quality level and value for money, while the 904 is moving up another notch in quality, and quite a bit in price...

White
2021 Charles Smith Riesling Kung Fu Girl Washington
11/7/2023 - macaujames Likes this wine:
90 points
89/90. A nice decently minerally freshly fruited medium dry honeyed Riesling which is drinkable and well priced. 12.5%.
PnP.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    11/24/23, 11:22 PM - Fun wine. Did you see this? https://tv.winelibrary.com/2008/10/01/a-very-cool-winemaker-visits-the-thunder-show-episode-549/

Red
2015 La Rioja Alta Rioja 904 Gran Reserva 'Selección Especial' Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
11/6/2023 - PSPatrick wrote:
93 points
Decanted for three hours. Medium to dark ruby colour. Red and blue fruit, red cherry, black raspberry, dill, dark chocolate, mocha, espresso, dark tobacco, spicecake and vanilla, with good acidity, round, well-integrated tannin, and very good length. Quite fresh, and quite elegant, with great persistence. The 2015 is not as complex and dense as the 2009 or 2010, and not as smooth as the 2011, but fresher, and it shows its class once paired with food. Great with slow-roasted goose. Should be interesting to compare the four vintages again in five years or so.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    11/14/23, 12:44 PM - That is a great question. And difficult to answer at this point. Initially I intended to rate the wine lower since it does not have the structure of the 2009 or the elegance and concentration of the 2010, and not even the smoothness of the 2011, and seems less age-worthy than e.g. the 2004. But I ended up rating ithe 2015 the same as the 2009 and 2011 since the wine really killed it paired with the slow-roasted goose. So what does that leave us with? The 2015 certainly is not superior to the 2009 and 2010 and consequently I would probably not support labeling it Selección Especial...

Red
1998 Chateau Musar Bekaa Valley Red Blend
5/12/2017 - CondorKhan wrote:
94 points
Chateau Musar Tasting: Very similar to the 1999, but a bit "cleaner". Sweet fruit is up in front, and the earthy funkiness takes more of a support role. Very nicely balanced and together. Licorice and olives add nice complexity. Finish has soft tannins and higher acidity. Up to that point, WOTN. The entire 98-00 trio had been outstanding, suggesting that 18-20 years is maturity for Musar.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    1/5/21, 11:25 PM - Thank you for the detailed notes on the vertical! I agree on the maturity, I am ususally drinking my Musars from about 18 years of age, and 1998, 2000 and 2002 are current favourites of mine.

    I am also fond of the more controversial 1997. It is not easy to like, is nowhere near as complete as any of the 1999, 2000 or 2002, but it is so intense and so different, and to me still holding back. And thanks to its acidity it also works well with fattier, richer meat dishes.

    Every bottle of Musar sort of takes you on a journey. They usually do not show well in a tasting setting but require taking time, great that it worked for you! Cheers!

  • PSPatrick commented:

    2/2/21, 10:58 AM - Just sourced a bottle of the 1994, a Musar vintage I haven't had yet. Looking forward to trying it!

  • PSPatrick commented:

    11/10/23, 8:12 AM - @CondorKhan: It took me almost three years before I finally got to pop the bottle of 1994 Chateau Musar I sourced based on your recommendation, but this week I did. As epic as you described. Truly exceptional. Thank you again for the recommendation! I also found bottles of 1993 and 1995 and look forward to comparing them to the 1994. I hope it will not take me another three years...

Red
2009 Château Batailley Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
11/4/2023 - PSPatrick wrote:
90 points
The wine seemed very tight upon opening, so I decided to aerate the wine in a decanter for three hours in the morning and poured the wine over dinner. The early decanting helped a little, the wine had opened up and the tannin had softened by dinner time. Medium to dark ruby colour, some sediment. Black currant, blackberry, blueberry, cherry, cedar, leather, light tobacco, light chocolate, graphite, intense spice, and vanilla, with medium-level acidity, firm tannin, and very good length. Good concentration on the attack, a little thinner in the middle and on the end, but it might flesh out with a few more years. The wine is still firm, and the tannin could use some more time to soften. I would drink from 2026. 90(+)(?)
  • PSPatrick commented:

    11/8/23, 10:26 PM - Nice to hear from you! I am glad that you are enjoying the Rieslings. Dönnhoff indeed is a great producer. I am currently experimenting with whites and reds from Jura, trying to find wines with low alcohol levels.

    2009 Château Batailley, agree 100% on the tannin. You may have sensed that I do have slight reservations about the wine nonetheless, because the tannin is there but the wine thinned out through the middle and end. While from a supposedly outstanding vintage, we need to see how this wine will age. It might flesh out with time but might also dry out if the fruit does not hold up. Have you had it?

Red
2020 Château de Beaucastel Côtes du Rhône Coudoulet de Beaucastel Red Rhone Blend
10/18/2023 - macaujames wrote:
92 points
91/92. Very juvenile, is very solid with black olives, leather, fruits of the forest, strawberries+ some iron filings hints. Ends mediumish, fresh and a bit unknit. 14%. Aerated this 6-7 hrs and is still opening up. Lay down 5-10 years+. This is not showing the normal silkiness of this wine yet. Maybe it needs more aeration.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    10/19/23, 12:24 AM - I love the Beaucastel CdP, and if you drink them young the Coudoulet is great value play!

Rosé
2021 Domaine Tempier Bandol Rosé Mourvèdre Blend, Mourvèdre
9/12/2023 - macaujames Likes this wine:
92 points
Wow the best rose ever! This is a classy ample delicious wine with lovely dry silky a bit saline garriguey peachy, rose petal notes,nice chalky minerality+freshness, fantastic elegance+excellent length and nice alcohol at 12.5%. Is intensely aromatic too! 92/93. On day two this is a 93!
  • PSPatrick commented:

    9/13/23, 6:14 AM - A great rosé, isn't it? Glad you liked it! I intended to stock up but never got to it. A pity.

White - Sparkling
2012 Dom Pérignon Champagne Champagne Blend
8/17/2023 - PSPatrick wrote:
95 points
At restaurant Domtrappkällaren in Uppsala, Sweden (great wine list!). Medium yellow-gold. Apple, lemon, pineapple, bread crust, nuts, chalk, and flint/smoke, with good acidity and impressive length. The mousse is super-fine and smooth. Really great persistence. It is easy to sense that there is more complexity to come with age, and yet the 2012 DP is very accessible and provides a lot of pleasure already. A great vintage for DP!
  • PSPatrick commented:

    9/11/23, 10:09 AM - Thank you. I got lucky in this case. The restaurant had the DP on its wine list at its retail price, no restaurant mark-up. I had the 2012 DP before, and it is a great champagne that can be enjoyed young, so I was unable to resist...

Red
2019 Château du Glana St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend
8/4/2023 - PSPatrick wrote:
90 points
At our cabin in Finland. Decanted for two hours. Dark ruby colour. Cabernet-driven. Good fruit. Black currant, dark cherry, blackberry, plum, bell pepper, dark chocolate, spices, vanilla, and a hint of mint, with good acidity, medium-fine tannin, and very good length. Lightly creamy texture. The generous oak is well-integrated. The alcohol (14.5% ABV) is lightly warming. Good concentration. Very ripe, and modern in style. More Chilean Cab than Bordeaux. Not my preferred style, but very easy-drinking, admittedly. I would drink over the medium term, until about 2040 that is.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    8/19/23, 4:03 AM - Agree. I have been looking at Bordeaux en-primeur 2022 and it is difficult to find a wine with an indicative ABV of less than 14.5%. I loved the low alcohol Bordeaux of the 80s, and am buying 2004s at the moment, but at some point it will become difficult to find Bordeaux at 13.5% and below. I am also looking at reds from Jura and keep reminding myself that I should drink more Beaujolais. I have not tried any wines from Brogsitter yet, thank you for the recommending. Enjoy the weekend!

Red
2016 Raka Quinary Klein River Red Bordeaux Blend
10/6/2019 - PSPatrick wrote:
87 points
A trip to South Africa's Coastal Region with Reni, Rainer and Bert. Day 9, Klein River Valley and Stellenbosch. Tasted at the winery, with owner Piet Dreyer and his second son and winemaker Josef.

Bordeaux blend of 45% Cabernet Sauvignon, 31% Merlot, 13% Cabernet Franc, 6% Malbec and 5% Petit Verdot. Medium ruby colour. Slightly muted nose. Red fruit, some dark fruit, vegetal and herbaceous notes, spices and some vanilla, with fresh but disharmonious acidity, dry and slightly chewy tannin, and average length. Slightly better concentration than the prior wines. Elegant style. Will need some time.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    7/16/23, 1:27 AM - Thank you!

White
2020 Weingut Robert Weil Kiedricher Gräfenberg Riesling Großes Gewächs Rheingau
4/18/2023 - PSPatrick wrote:
92 points
Now this is nice! Physalis, pink grapefruit, tangerine, peach, apple, lemon, and mineral notes, with good acidity and great persistence. Good concentration, and good complexity. Balanced and harmonious despite of its youth. Great Riesling! 92(+)
  • PSPatrick commented:

    7/12/23, 9:26 AM - Certainly a great choice for your first Riesling! Glad you liked it.

    Another great producer from the Rheingau area is Weingut Künstler. If you like a fuller style, Weingut Korrell from the Nahe region is an option with good value for money. If you want to try a leaner, even more acidic style you could try Rieslings from the Mosel region.

Red
2005 La Rioja Alta Rioja Viña Ardanza Reserva Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
6/25/2023 - PSPatrick wrote:
92 points
I have not opened a bottle of the Ardanza Reserva 2005 since 2016. Back then, I noted significant bottle variation (maybe it is the corks as suggested by some of the notes below). Well, either this time I picked a bottle at the top end of the variation curve, or the wine has developed nicely over the last few years. Cork in perfect condition. Medium to dark ruby colour. Red fruit, leather, coffee, chocolate, dill, intense spice notes, vanilla, and clove, with fresh acidity and very good length. The wine kept improving with aeration and was well-balanced, with good concentration, and complexity. No arguing, a very good Rioja that is in a great spot.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    7/12/23, 4:52 AM - I share your enthusiasm. I stocked quite a few bottles of the 2005, and still have a case and three mags left. The wine will keep, but it is in such a great spot that I will probably drink my regular bottles over the next few years.

    Have you already had a chance to try the 2015 Gran Reserva 904? (I have not)

White
2005 Querbach Oestricher Lenchen Riesling Q1 Rheingau
5/2/2023 - PSPatrick wrote:
90 points
Crown cap. Medium yellow golden colour. Dried apricot, tangerine, ripe citrus, wild honey, Earl Grey tea, ethereal notes, and stony minerality, with good acidity and good length. Good body, and an oily texture. The wine benefited from aeration in a small decanter. In a good place; drink now and over the next three or four years.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    5/8/23, 6:11 AM - Yes, and value for money Querbach is among my favourites. They still have older vintage back to 2001 in stock, which they sell at reasonable prices.

    Querbach organized an open tasting with more than 100 wines just the other weekend, and the 2001s, 2002s, 2011s and 2012s showed very well this time.

    Thank you for pointing me to the Grosset Rieslings! I have not had the Polish Hill Riesling yet, but I have been able to order a mixed case of 2021 Polish Hill, Springvale and Alea. Looking forward to trying them. Thanks again!

Red
2018 4 Kilos Vi de La Tierra Mallorca 12 Volts Red Blend
2/6/2023 - macaujames wrote:
90 points
90/91. Elegant juicy linear lightly oaked forest fruited wine with nice elegance and length. 12%. I dont know how they could do such a low abv on Majorca!
  • PSPatrick commented:

    4/21/23, 2:34 AM - Isn't it amazing? A friend of mine lives in Palma de Mallorca and we have shared quite a few of the 4 Kilos. Such elegance from such a warm place. A really interesting project. An great marketing. I love the Wine Song Video they did: http://www.4kilos.com/index.php?/ruralhome/the-wine-song/

  • PSPatrick commented:

    4/25/23, 10:10 PM - I am looking forward to reading about the German Pinot Noirs! The category is a favourite of mine, as you know. But other than a 1990 Spätburgunder by Meyer-Näkel that was past its peak but still enjoyable, I did not get to drink any lately...

Red
1978 Caves Velhas Romeira Garrafeira Vinho Regional Lisboa Red Blend
1/18/2019 - PSPatrick wrote:
90 points
“G8 summit – Milestones and memories of my past” (non-blind), Wine 8: The year in which my dear friend and generous host moved from the U.S. to England. The wine was medium to dark ruby in colour and offered red, blue and black fruit, gingerbread and spices on the nose. On the palate, the wine showed red and dark fruit, gingerbread, spices and a mild vegetal component, with good acidity, fully resolved tannin and very good length. Full on life and well-balanced.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    3/31/23, 1:22 AM - Thank you for reaching out and apologies for the delayed response!

    These wines typically age very well if kept in a good cellar. A 1976 should be ready to drink, with limited upside potential, even from magnum. If cellared well, it should continue to keep, but I doubt that it would improve. I would drink since even magnums only sell at around €80.

Red
1998 Chateau Musar Bekaa Valley Red Blend
3/8/2023 - PSPatrick wrote:
93 points
Ex Château 2022. Filled into the neck, cork intact. Decanted for four hours in the morning, poured over dinner. Medium to light garnet colour, a little lighter in colour than expected, some sediment. Red fruit, red plum, cedar, tobacco, spices, gamy notes, and some VA. Finishes balsamic, and then turns gamy, cedary and smoky again on the aftertaste. All carried by great acidity. The tannin is fully resolved, and the wine is smoothly textured, with some old age sweetness. Drinks like a 60% Mourvèdre and 40% Grenache blend from a cool climate. Good concentration and complexity. In a great place! I have said it before, and it is still true: This is a captivating bottle of wine!
  • PSPatrick commented:

    3/11/23, 1:08 PM - I share your love for Musar. Drinking the 2000 right now. Very different from the 1998, but equally good in its own way.

    Harrods… haven’t been there in years. My wife and I loved their tasting selections over lunch. Brings back memories. I truly miss living in London.

    Wish one could still buy Musar at 12 Pounds nowadays. But Musars are still affordable nowadays,
    comparatively, until they are about 20 years old.

    Enjoy your weekend!

Red
1989 La Rioja Alta Rioja Gran Reserva 904 Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
11/23/2021 - PSPatrick wrote:
92 points
First of three bottles I bought on auction recently (€65/bottle). Red fruit, strawberry, red cherry, dill, tobacco, and spices, with good acidity, partly resolved tannin, and very good length.

The remaining tannin seems grainy at first, but finds its balance after some time in the decanter. By day two, the tannin is fully resolved and flavors are very integrated. The fruit is riper than expected, but other than that this is a classic, old school Rioja.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    2/7/23, 10:18 AM - Sure. Munich Wine Company (https://www.munichwinecompany.com/en/index.html). For full disclosure, I have made mixed experiences with lots auctioned by Munich Wine Company and am no longer buying on that platform.

Red
1985 Château Calon-Ségur St. Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend
1/28/2023 - PSPatrick wrote:
93 points
Decanted for 90 minutes. Medium garnet colour. Cherry, red and dark berries, prune, intense cedar, complex spice notes, mint, and balsamic notes, all carried by fresh acidity. Beautiful old-age sweetness. The tannin is fully resolved, and the wine is very smoothly textured, with great persistence. Well-structured, with good complexity, and good concentration. Great Bordeaux!
  • PSPatrick commented:

    2/4/23, 11:22 PM - Happy belated New Year, James!
    My notes say that the wine might have been 13% ABV, but I am not sure. I wish all reds would be between 12.5 and 13.0 nowadays... cheers to old wines!

Red
2010 Luddite Wines Shiraz Bot River
12/19/2020 - PSPatrick Does not like this wine:
89 points
A recent library late release by the winery. Decanted for one hour. Inky dark ruby colour. Ripe fruit - dark cherry, blackberry, plum, dates and fig - followed by pastille and spice notes, and finally joined by lots of dark chocolate on the finish, with medium-fine, slightly drying tannin, medium-level acidity and very good length. Some warmth from the alcohol. Dark, concentrated and ambitious, but not special. Overripe, over extracted and overpriced.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    2/4/23, 11:18 PM - Thank you for your feedback. I am still sitting on another bottle and will at some point try it with even more air.

Red
2010 R. López de Heredia Rioja Reserva Viña Bosconia Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
11/15/2022 - PSPatrick wrote:
91 points
Decanted for one hour. Medium to dark ruby colour. Red fruit, bluebery, dill, tobacco, spices, cinnamon, vanilla, and light smoke, with great acidity, well-integrated tannin, and very good length. Medium-bodied, with notable acidity that asks for hearty food. Consistent over a period of three days. Very young. Hold, and start drinking from 2028.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    12/3/22, 6:32 AM - Thank you, James! I did not even notice, but you are right, it seems that I have awarded my 500,000th point. It will probably only be another ten years until I add the seventh digit ;)

    Have a great weekend!

Red
2010 R. López de Heredia Rioja Reserva Viña Tondonia Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
9/9/2022 - macaujames Likes this wine:
95 points
Profound and racy has light clovey hints! Easily the Best Tondonia ever. Has excellent length on day two. 13%. I salute Queen Elizabeth's life! This should be bought by the case! Lay down 20-40 years+drink now too! Needs 90 mins aeration. I had this with lamb fillet and this was a wonderful match! This is a little Bourguinon but very Riojan with its juicy lipsmacking garlicky food friendly acidity!
  • PSPatrick commented:

    9/9/22, 11:02 PM - That sounds promising. And I like the 13% ABV. Many producers have moved in a different direction... Congrats on TN #1,500!

Red
1985 La Rioja Alta Rioja Viña Ardanza Reserva Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
8/23/2022 - PSPatrick wrote:
92 points
Bought recently, from a different source than the last bottle. In great condition. Medium garnet colour. Red fruit, dill, coffee, light cedar, tobacco, intense spice, cinnamon, clove, vanilla, and balsamic notes, with medium-level acidity, fully resolved tannin, and great persistence. Smoothly textured and well balanced. Has everything one would be looking for in mature, traditional-style Rioja. Equally enjoyable on day two. Drink now.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    9/4/22, 12:56 AM - I really liked the 85. I have three more bottles from three different sources and look forward to drinking them over the next five years or so.

    Both, the 85 and the 89, state 13% ABV on the label, according to my notes.

    I only had the 89 once, fairly recently, and noted pronounced acidity and light bitterness, which would indicate that the wine should be paired with food.

  • PSPatrick commented:

    9/9/22, 11:00 PM - That sounds promising! Thank you for the recommendation! I already have a few bottles of each of the 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, and 2008 in the cellar and considered sitting the next few vintages out, but based on your recommendation I will probably add a case of the 2010 and stop there. When would you drink the 2010s?

Red
2017 Ziereisen Rhini Baden Spätburgunder, Pinot Noir
9/2/2022 - PSPatrick wrote:
88 points
Medium ruby colour. Cherry, red fruit, chlorine, forest notes, and light spice, with good acidity and good length. Juicy fruit, and good concentration. But the fine tannin is sandpapery and drying which makes it difficult to enjoy the wine at its current stage. The last glass I had on day one after three hours in a decanter drank best. However, by day three the wine was disjointed and undrinkable. I am concerned if this wine will ever come around, but the juicy fruit raises my hopes, and Ziereisen‘s Pinot Noirs typically need at decade to show best, so this wine still might have its moment in a few years. I would hold for five or six years. 88(+)(?)
  • PSPatrick commented:

    9/7/22, 12:56 AM - No, this was a let-down. And I am not fully convinced that it will come around. I have made mixed experiences with the Rhini. To me, Ziereisen's Jaspis Pinot Noir bottlings and the whites are more reliable. This was the third German Pinot Noir from the 2017 vintage I have tried, and Frank John's Kalkstein Pinot Noir and Holger Koch's Pinot Noir Reserve were beautiful, so it is not the vintage in general.

Red
2019 Sermann Mayschoss Spätburgunder Ahr
7/7/2021 - macaujames wrote:
87 points
The Sermann Spatburgunder has been renamed. It should be Mayschosser Spätburgunder.Not particularly aromatic at the moment. It has 12.5% abv and is very drinkable and nicely silky but a bit hot blue and red fruits and with good oak. I got it on offer at 9 Euros but at the normal price this is not fantastic QPR at the moment. These bottles always improve with a year's laydown.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    9/4/22, 12:48 AM - I have to admit that you were right about Sermann's 2019 Spätburgunder. I was not convinced on first impression, but they are developing well, in particular the Altenahrer Eck. I am inclined to accept your recommendation and stock a few bottles of the current releases. Thanks again!

Spirits
N.V. Southern Comfort Louisiana Orange
7/3/2022 - Soteriologist Likes this wine:
87 points
Most delightful alcopop ever: liquified chewing gum, but that shouldn't subtract from the quality being way above my expectations. The wood is good, and, besides the dried bananas, I swear (notice the "skunk" element) there's some potentilla erecta in this. This being too sweet soon, throw 4 - 6 cl of this together with a fresh pressed lemon and you're set: at 10 € for 70 cl a no brainer for a summer mixer.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    7/4/22, 9:41 AM - Plus, it comes with a headache for free ;)

  • PSPatrick commented:

    7/4/22, 12:28 PM - Get well soon!

Red
2008 R. López de Heredia Rioja Reserva Viña Tondonia Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
6/29/2022 - macaujames Likes this wine:
92 points
Idiosyncratic as always! Has reserved aromas of clove hints, blackberries, leather, bricks, forest fruits and cherries. Its medium bodied earthy supple zingy clove flecked forest fruits palate has impressive depth and ends longish and tangy. Needs 5-6 hrs aeration. Lay down 5 years+.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    7/1/22, 7:12 AM - I had not had a Tondonia Reserva in about three years and was wary about opening the 2008 when it came out since the bottling can be demanding at times. It was as a positive and welcome surprise that the 2008 is well-behaved despite of its youth... textbook Rioja.

White - Sparkling
N.V. Pol Roger Champagne Brut Réserve Champagne Blend
6/30/2022 - macaujames Likes this wine:
91 points
Has complex aromas of brioche, minerals, limes, straw+hay, toasty stonefruits+veggies. Its stylish+refined layered, honeyed light to medium bodied briochey, minerally stonefruits palate has lovely perlage+depth. Ends longish, fresh and balanced. 12.5%. Good depth. Lay down 10-20 years+. The best Champagne I have had for a long time! 91/92.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    7/1/22, 7:05 AM - It has become posh to go for grower champagnes and luxury cuvées, but the Pol Roger Réserve is a very reliable bottling and rarely disappoints. I agree that it can easily age for 10+ years after release and usually benefits from additional time in the cellar.

White - Sparkling
N.V. Pol Roger Champagne Brut Réserve Champagne Blend
5/2/2022 - PSPatrick wrote:
91 points
A bottle I bought back in 2017 and kept in my cellar since. Bright medium yellow gold. Stone fruit, ripe apple, ripe citrus, floral notes, nuts, biscuit, bread crust, brioche, and smoke. Medium- to full-bodied, with complex autolytic character, good acidity, fine, creamy mousse, and great persistence. Intriguing Aspirin-like bitterness on the finish. Very reliable, the Pol Roger Brut Réserve is one of my few go-to big house champagnes.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    7/1/22, 7:00 AM - Same!

Red
2017 Palacios Remondo Rioja La Montesa Grenache Blend, Grenache
6/3/2022 - PSPatrick wrote:
91 points
Medium ruby colour. Beautiful red and dark berry notes, wild raspberry, cherry, blueberry, blackberry, light coffee, some dark chocolate, spices, light vanilla, and liquorice, with fresh acidity, round tannin, and very good length. The medium-bodied wine is smoothly textured and lightly creamy, with good complexity, good balance, and impressive purity of fruit. Very pleasant! Even more enjoyable than the very good 2018. Very good value! A great wine for everyday drinking.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    6/20/22, 11:00 PM - We did, thank you. I enjoyed a long weekend with my family in London, felt like coming home. I hope you also enjoyed the day off?

    I really like the La Montesa, both the 2017 and the 2018. The affordable wine should appeal to most, which makes it the perfect wine not only for weekday and lunchtime drinking, but also for get-togethers. That said, while I usually like my wines with plenty of age, as an exception to the rule I would not buy the La Montesa for cellaring but for the purpose of immediate consump-tion. There is no doubt that the wine will last ten years if stored properly, but I do not see it im-proving with more age, and there are other options to choose from which would gain more from cellaring than the La Montesa. What do you think?

Red
2018 Comm. G.B. Burlotto Barolo Nebbiolo
5/24/2022 - PSPatrick wrote:
91 points
Medium ruby colour. Red cherry, red fruit, rose water, iodine, rusty nail, a hint of cocoa, spice notes, and earth, with good acidity, round tannin, and very good length of the dry finish. Medium- to full-bodied, with a smooth, lightly creamy texture. Very earthy. Very well-balanced despite of its youth. Feminine, harmonious, and very Burgundian on day two.

The beautiful 2018 Burlotto Barolo is enjoyable upon opening, and shows best after four hours of aeration in a wide decanter. Drink now, and over the medium term.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    6/5/22, 1:04 AM - Thank you for your feedback! I see your point and will adjust my note. To your question, I was offered a mixed six-case of Burlotto's 2018s at €339, consisting of the Barolo, two bottles of Barolo Acclivi, and one bottle each of Barolo Cannubi, Barolo Castelletto, and Barolo Monvigliero. Consequently, in my calculation I only paid €30 to €35 for the regular Barolo, which is excellent value for money. I would still stock up at €40 or €45 since the wine provides great drinking pleasure in this youthful state, but fully agree that there is no point in spending much more than that.

White
2020 Post House Chenin Blanc Stamp of Chenin Stellenbosch
7/12/2021 - PSPatrick wrote:
90 points
Casually tasting eight samples with my wife (double-blind): Sample 4 of 8, prepared by a friend and dropped off at my door spontaneously, tasted double-blind. Citrus, herbal notes, smoke, light spice, and well-integrated oak, with lively acidity and very good length. Buttery texture. Good concentration and complexity. Reminds me of the Diemersdal MM Louw Sauvignon Blanc 2018 we drank the other day. I liked it.
  • PSPatrick commented:

    1/5/22, 11:44 PM - Ein frohes neues Jahr! Die Flasche habe ich bei einem befreundeten Weinhändler im Taunus erstanden, von dem ich fast alle meine SA Weine so wie auch viele Spanier, Portugiesen und Rhône-Weine beziehe. Neben fairen Preisen hat er insbesondere immer auch ältere Jahrgänge. Bei Bedarf kann ich gerne Kontakt herstellen.

  • PSPatrick commented:

    2/9/22, 8:51 AM - Hi Srog! Ich bringe Euch gerne zusammen. Wenn Du mir Deine Email-Adresse zukommen lässt (zum Beispiel indem Du sie in einem Kommentar hier postest und den Kommentar anschließend gleich wieder löschst), stelle ich den Kontakt her.

Red
2007 Ziereisen Pinot Noir Jaspis Baden
2/1/2022 - PSPatrick wrote:
91 points
From 45-year-old vines. Maceration for a full ten weeks, followed by 20 months in barrique (20% new). Unfiltered. Only 12.5% ABV. Bought recently.

Medium garnet colour. Only opened up slowly, and the last glass after six hours drank best. Cherry, mushroom, iodine, and Pinot spice, with medium acidity, mostly resolved tannin and great persistence. Smoothly textured and well-balanced. All about balance and harmony, not power or complexity. One of the most Burgundian German Spätburgunders I have seen (and one of the very few Pinot Noirs that drank better from Zalto Denk'Art Burgundy glasses than from Riedel Sommerlier Burgundy glasses). Quite beautiful!
  • PSPatrick commented:

    2/9/22, 8:46 AM - Thank you for your comment! I fully agree, the Zalto Denk'Art Burgundy glasses rarely work for me. I like them for Beaujolais Cru, and occasionally for experimenting with Champagnes, but other than that they usually disappoint me. The bigger was the surprise when they brought out the best in the 2007 Jaspis PN that did not show well from any other glass.

    Thank you for mentioning your difficulties with finding the right glass for the 2005 Alte Reben. I have pulled a bottle from the cellar recently with the intention of opening it the next weeks, and will also try it with the Zalto. Would you have a recommendation regarding decanting/ideal time for aeration of the 2005 Alte Reben?

1 - 50 of 884
More results
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close