5/6/24, 4:47 AM - Thank you for your note. I used to like the 2009 quite a bit when it was young, and the 2010 at six, seven years of age, and agree that this Château typically offers excellent value for money (in Bordeaux terms). That said, I have lost track of the bottling after the disappointing 2011, and should probably try a few younger vintages like this 2016.
5/6/24, 4:40 AM - I toured wineries in the Cape region in 2019, but did not make it to Hartenberg, unfortunately. I have heard good things about the Paul Sauer and realize that I have a few bottles of 2011 and 2012 in the cellar but have never tried one yet. Need to find those bottles. Thank you for the recommendation!
5/6/24, 4:33 AM - Thank you for your feedback and comment! I have had a few different vintages of the Harten-berg Chardonnay and liked all of them quite a bit at about age 7 to 11 years from vintage. The Hartenberg Chardonnay’s indeed age well and offer excellent value for money. But I do not have a good overview of South African Chardonnays in general: I have tried Chardonnay’s from about 15 different producers in South Africa, with some good results (Delaire Graff's Chardonnay Re-serve Banghoek showed particularly well), but I typically opt for Chenin Blanc instead. That said, I had the Hamilton Russel 1997 at age 24 and it was still enjoyable if, admittedly, on the down-ward sloop. I never got a chance to try the Five Soldiers or the Eleanor though and am thankful for your feedback on the two.
4/22/24, 6:32 AM - Yes, at €25-30 a bottle we would probably be drinking Lynch-Bages all the time! And your 1996 should drink well now, I presume. The 2000 was still firm and restrained, which is consistent with a few other top 2000s I tried recently. For that reason, at the moment I would rather drink 2003s and 2004s, and hold the 2000s for a few years, at least at the top levels. I have not had any 2005s lately and will need to try a few to find out where they are in terms of evolution. Have you? Any thoughts?
4/21/24, 7:22 AM - Sure, will do!
3/15/24, 8:51 AM - With no decanter available, popped and poured and straight from bottle, it is surprising that the wine was enjoyable already, and that it was fully open on day two. If you give it just some aeration in a decanter, it is ready to drink now.
4/11/24, 8:10 AM - @macaujames: That sounds exciting indeed. Looking forward to hearing more! With limited exposure to Château d'Issan in the past due to a few early disappointments, I find the more recent releases much more compelling than pre-2015 vintages I have had.
4/7/24, 1:55 AM - Fully agree on the quality of the Canons from the 80's, and would also throw '83 in the mix of the vintages you mentioned.
3/7/24, 12:51 AM - I can see why you liked the 2015 Beaucastel. I only tried it once, when it was very young, and was impressed. I put a case in storage and will probably leave it there for another five years. The 2007 is amazing now, by the way.
3/7/24, 12:49 AM - On sale at Schreiblehner, recently, very good value at €29. The 2000 I had a few years ago also showed well, very ethereal. I bought a bottle of each of the 2019 CdP Vieilles Vignes, 2021 CdP Pi, and 2022 Blanc as well and intend to try them over the next few weeks.
2/29/24, 12:56 AM - Can't say, I am sorry. I have not tried the 2010 yet. If I had to guess, I would expect the 2010 to be superior, more structured, firmer, and longer lived based on vintage. I am a little jealous, I missed the opportunity to secure me a case.
2/16/24, 6:27 AM - I agree with your conclusion. Despite of the reputation of the producer and the warm vintage, the wine is pretty harsh on the palate, an rustic overall, and does not provide much pleasure.
2/12/24, 8:41 AM - I have had a few nice young Bordeaux recently, slowly working through a mixed case of 24 different half bottles of crus classés (mostly from the 2016 to 2020 vintages). 2015 Brane-Cantenac was very accessible and quite beautiful, and 2020 Beausejour Duffau Lagarrosse had impressive structure, concentration and complexity (but needs time). But the 2018 Pichon Baron stood out. It breaks the bank, but I could not help it, I had to get a case and put it into storage.I have never had the Thalabert. Thank you for mentioning it. Will keep my eyes open.
1/30/24, 9:23 AM - @macaujames: Always happy to taste a wine for you ;)I bought a few bottles of 85, 87 and 89 Ardanza Reserva from different sources recently. From the bottles I sourced the 85 showed best; a classic, mature, smoothly textured and well-balanced Rioja. The 87 also showed well, even if not as smoothly textured as one would expect from a 30+ year-old wine. The 89 was a little mor difficult, the acidity was pronounced and there was some bitterness on the finish. There will be a lot of bottle variation depending on provenance, but based on the bottle I had it might be worth checking in on your bottles of 89 to see how they are doing.
1/30/24, 9:37 AM - @belfast taxman: I agree, it really is impressive how well many Riojas age, even at Reserva level. I have had amazing Reservas from the 60s and 70s and love the style. But I admit that I have had mixed experiences with aged Ardanza Reservas recently and will now monitor their development very closely once they are 25+ years old.Château Prieuré-Lichine is a different story for me since I used to like the Château a lot, in par-ticular for the value for money, and the 86, 88 and 89 have aged very well and still are beautiful wines. That said, I am disappointed with the vintages of the 90s and early 2000s, and have start-ed to sell my stock in 1999, 2000 and 2001 Château Prieuré-Lichine. I had also bought 2015 and 2019, which I have not tried yet, and hope that they are back to the old standards...
1/27/24, 3:11 AM - In case you are interested, Wein-Refugium currently runs a sale and some Bertram wines are available at a 30% discount. The Frühburgunder is exceptional. I also recommend Holger Koch’s Pinot Noirs, in particular Holger Koch’s Spätburgunder *** 2016.
12/26/23, 12:54 AM - Agree. The salty and volcanic character makes these wines quite unique. The Envinate wines are my favourite so far, and for a more oaky style maybe the Suertes del Marqués Vidonia from Tenerife.
12/23/23, 3:28 AM - Now that is a good question. Funnily, I am not sure. I think it was Filet Mignon (no sauce). It must not have worked well since if it had softened the tannin I would have included it in my note.
12/11/23, 12:00 AM - Agree 100%. I was surprised by the lack of freshness and by how developed the wine tasted. I am generally cautious with 2017 and 2018 Barolos but found that some are dinking well early on. This one may never shine...
1/9/18, 5:36 AM - I haven't had it before, but am very curious how it develops over the next 25 years or so!
12/8/23, 10:36 PM - Nice! I haven't tried an Haut-Serre in a while. And your comment raises the question where I have buried the case of this Cuvée Prestige which I bought at the time... ?!?
12/4/23, 10:03 PM - The Ardanza seems to be replacing the 904 of the earlier 2000s in terms of quality level and value for money, while the 904 is moving up another notch in quality, and quite a bit in price...
11/24/23, 11:22 PM - Fun wine. Did you see this? https://tv.winelibrary.com/2008/10/01/a-very-cool-winemaker-visits-the-thunder-show-episode-549/
11/14/23, 12:44 PM - That is a great question. And difficult to answer at this point. Initially I intended to rate the wine lower since it does not have the structure of the 2009 or the elegance and concentration of the 2010, and not even the smoothness of the 2011, and seems less age-worthy than e.g. the 2004. But I ended up rating ithe 2015 the same as the 2009 and 2011 since the wine really killed it paired with the slow-roasted goose. So what does that leave us with? The 2015 certainly is not superior to the 2009 and 2010 and consequently I would probably not support labeling it Selección Especial...
1/5/21, 11:25 PM - Thank you for the detailed notes on the vertical! I agree on the maturity, I am ususally drinking my Musars from about 18 years of age, and 1998, 2000 and 2002 are current favourites of mine.I am also fond of the more controversial 1997. It is not easy to like, is nowhere near as complete as any of the 1999, 2000 or 2002, but it is so intense and so different, and to me still holding back. And thanks to its acidity it also works well with fattier, richer meat dishes.Every bottle of Musar sort of takes you on a journey. They usually do not show well in a tasting setting but require taking time, great that it worked for you! Cheers!
2/2/21, 10:58 AM - Just sourced a bottle of the 1994, a Musar vintage I haven't had yet. Looking forward to trying it!
11/10/23, 8:12 AM - @CondorKhan: It took me almost three years before I finally got to pop the bottle of 1994 Chateau Musar I sourced based on your recommendation, but this week I did. As epic as you described. Truly exceptional. Thank you again for the recommendation! I also found bottles of 1993 and 1995 and look forward to comparing them to the 1994. I hope it will not take me another three years...
11/8/23, 10:26 PM - Nice to hear from you! I am glad that you are enjoying the Rieslings. Dönnhoff indeed is a great producer. I am currently experimenting with whites and reds from Jura, trying to find wines with low alcohol levels.2009 Château Batailley, agree 100% on the tannin. You may have sensed that I do have slight reservations about the wine nonetheless, because the tannin is there but the wine thinned out through the middle and end. While from a supposedly outstanding vintage, we need to see how this wine will age. It might flesh out with time but might also dry out if the fruit does not hold up. Have you had it?
10/19/23, 12:24 AM - I love the Beaucastel CdP, and if you drink them young the Coudoulet is great value play!
9/13/23, 6:14 AM - A great rosé, isn't it? Glad you liked it! I intended to stock up but never got to it. A pity.
9/11/23, 10:09 AM - Thank you. I got lucky in this case. The restaurant had the DP on its wine list at its retail price, no restaurant mark-up. I had the 2012 DP before, and it is a great champagne that can be enjoyed young, so I was unable to resist...
8/19/23, 4:03 AM - Agree. I have been looking at Bordeaux en-primeur 2022 and it is difficult to find a wine with an indicative ABV of less than 14.5%. I loved the low alcohol Bordeaux of the 80s, and am buying 2004s at the moment, but at some point it will become difficult to find Bordeaux at 13.5% and below. I am also looking at reds from Jura and keep reminding myself that I should drink more Beaujolais. I have not tried any wines from Brogsitter yet, thank you for the recommending. Enjoy the weekend!
7/16/23, 1:27 AM - Thank you!
7/12/23, 9:26 AM - Certainly a great choice for your first Riesling! Glad you liked it.Another great producer from the Rheingau area is Weingut Künstler. If you like a fuller style, Weingut Korrell from the Nahe region is an option with good value for money. If you want to try a leaner, even more acidic style you could try Rieslings from the Mosel region.
7/12/23, 4:52 AM - I share your enthusiasm. I stocked quite a few bottles of the 2005, and still have a case and three mags left. The wine will keep, but it is in such a great spot that I will probably drink my regular bottles over the next few years.Have you already had a chance to try the 2015 Gran Reserva 904? (I have not)
5/8/23, 6:11 AM - Yes, and value for money Querbach is among my favourites. They still have older vintage back to 2001 in stock, which they sell at reasonable prices. Querbach organized an open tasting with more than 100 wines just the other weekend, and the 2001s, 2002s, 2011s and 2012s showed very well this time.Thank you for pointing me to the Grosset Rieslings! I have not had the Polish Hill Riesling yet, but I have been able to order a mixed case of 2021 Polish Hill, Springvale and Alea. Looking forward to trying them. Thanks again!
4/21/23, 2:34 AM - Isn't it amazing? A friend of mine lives in Palma de Mallorca and we have shared quite a few of the 4 Kilos. Such elegance from such a warm place. A really interesting project. An great marketing. I love the Wine Song Video they did: http://www.4kilos.com/index.php?/ruralhome/the-wine-song/
4/25/23, 10:10 PM - I am looking forward to reading about the German Pinot Noirs! The category is a favourite of mine, as you know. But other than a 1990 Spätburgunder by Meyer-Näkel that was past its peak but still enjoyable, I did not get to drink any lately...
3/31/23, 1:22 AM - Thank you for reaching out and apologies for the delayed response!These wines typically age very well if kept in a good cellar. A 1976 should be ready to drink, with limited upside potential, even from magnum. If cellared well, it should continue to keep, but I doubt that it would improve. I would drink since even magnums only sell at around €80.
3/11/23, 1:08 PM - I share your love for Musar. Drinking the 2000 right now. Very different from the 1998, but equally good in its own way.Harrods… haven’t been there in years. My wife and I loved their tasting selections over lunch. Brings back memories. I truly miss living in London.Wish one could still buy Musar at 12 Pounds nowadays. But Musars are still affordable nowadays,comparatively, until they are about 20 years old. Enjoy your weekend!
2/7/23, 10:18 AM - Sure. Munich Wine Company (https://www.munichwinecompany.com/en/index.html). For full disclosure, I have made mixed experiences with lots auctioned by Munich Wine Company and am no longer buying on that platform.
2/4/23, 11:22 PM - Happy belated New Year, James!My notes say that the wine might have been 13% ABV, but I am not sure. I wish all reds would be between 12.5 and 13.0 nowadays... cheers to old wines!
2/4/23, 11:18 PM - Thank you for your feedback. I am still sitting on another bottle and will at some point try it with even more air.
12/3/22, 6:32 AM - Thank you, James! I did not even notice, but you are right, it seems that I have awarded my 500,000th point. It will probably only be another ten years until I add the seventh digit ;)Have a great weekend!
9/9/22, 11:02 PM - That sounds promising. And I like the 13% ABV. Many producers have moved in a different direction... Congrats on TN #1,500!
9/4/22, 12:56 AM - I really liked the 85. I have three more bottles from three different sources and look forward to drinking them over the next five years or so.Both, the 85 and the 89, state 13% ABV on the label, according to my notes.I only had the 89 once, fairly recently, and noted pronounced acidity and light bitterness, which would indicate that the wine should be paired with food.
9/9/22, 11:00 PM - That sounds promising! Thank you for the recommendation! I already have a few bottles of each of the 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, and 2008 in the cellar and considered sitting the next few vintages out, but based on your recommendation I will probably add a case of the 2010 and stop there. When would you drink the 2010s?
9/7/22, 12:56 AM - No, this was a let-down. And I am not fully convinced that it will come around. I have made mixed experiences with the Rhini. To me, Ziereisen's Jaspis Pinot Noir bottlings and the whites are more reliable. This was the third German Pinot Noir from the 2017 vintage I have tried, and Frank John's Kalkstein Pinot Noir and Holger Koch's Pinot Noir Reserve were beautiful, so it is not the vintage in general.
9/4/22, 12:48 AM - I have to admit that you were right about Sermann's 2019 Spätburgunder. I was not convinced on first impression, but they are developing well, in particular the Altenahrer Eck. I am inclined to accept your recommendation and stock a few bottles of the current releases. Thanks again!
7/4/22, 9:41 AM - Plus, it comes with a headache for free ;)
7/4/22, 12:28 PM - Get well soon!
7/1/22, 7:12 AM - I had not had a Tondonia Reserva in about three years and was wary about opening the 2008 when it came out since the bottling can be demanding at times. It was as a positive and welcome surprise that the 2008 is well-behaved despite of its youth... textbook Rioja.
7/1/22, 7:05 AM - It has become posh to go for grower champagnes and luxury cuvées, but the Pol Roger Réserve is a very reliable bottling and rarely disappoints. I agree that it can easily age for 10+ years after release and usually benefits from additional time in the cellar.
7/1/22, 7:00 AM - Same!
6/20/22, 11:00 PM - We did, thank you. I enjoyed a long weekend with my family in London, felt like coming home. I hope you also enjoyed the day off?I really like the La Montesa, both the 2017 and the 2018. The affordable wine should appeal to most, which makes it the perfect wine not only for weekday and lunchtime drinking, but also for get-togethers. That said, while I usually like my wines with plenty of age, as an exception to the rule I would not buy the La Montesa for cellaring but for the purpose of immediate consump-tion. There is no doubt that the wine will last ten years if stored properly, but I do not see it im-proving with more age, and there are other options to choose from which would gain more from cellaring than the La Montesa. What do you think?
6/5/22, 1:04 AM - Thank you for your feedback! I see your point and will adjust my note. To your question, I was offered a mixed six-case of Burlotto's 2018s at €339, consisting of the Barolo, two bottles of Barolo Acclivi, and one bottle each of Barolo Cannubi, Barolo Castelletto, and Barolo Monvigliero. Consequently, in my calculation I only paid €30 to €35 for the regular Barolo, which is excellent value for money. I would still stock up at €40 or €45 since the wine provides great drinking pleasure in this youthful state, but fully agree that there is no point in spending much more than that.
1/5/22, 11:44 PM - Ein frohes neues Jahr! Die Flasche habe ich bei einem befreundeten Weinhändler im Taunus erstanden, von dem ich fast alle meine SA Weine so wie auch viele Spanier, Portugiesen und Rhône-Weine beziehe. Neben fairen Preisen hat er insbesondere immer auch ältere Jahrgänge. Bei Bedarf kann ich gerne Kontakt herstellen.
2/9/22, 8:51 AM - Hi Srog! Ich bringe Euch gerne zusammen. Wenn Du mir Deine Email-Adresse zukommen lässt (zum Beispiel indem Du sie in einem Kommentar hier postest und den Kommentar anschließend gleich wieder löschst), stelle ich den Kontakt her.
2/9/22, 8:46 AM - Thank you for your comment! I fully agree, the Zalto Denk'Art Burgundy glasses rarely work for me. I like them for Beaujolais Cru, and occasionally for experimenting with Champagnes, but other than that they usually disappoint me. The bigger was the surprise when they brought out the best in the 2007 Jaspis PN that did not show well from any other glass.Thank you for mentioning your difficulties with finding the right glass for the 2005 Alte Reben. I have pulled a bottle from the cellar recently with the intention of opening it the next weeks, and will also try it with the Zalto. Would you have a recommendation regarding decanting/ideal time for aeration of the 2005 Alte Reben?
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search